It is fair to say I rarely find myself lapsing into praise for the system of justice that prevails in Northern Ireland, or indeed for the judges who preside over the courts there.
To maintain the spirit of fairness, I should also say that I am not entirely impartial. In the days when I covered Irish affairs, a lot of money was once awarded in respect of an article I had written.
Now that did not seem especially fair at the time; the Daily Telegraph's leading counsel had described me as one of the finest witnesses he had seen in a Belfast court. But at least his praise meant that when I returned to London, I was treated as hero of the hour, perhaps having stopped the damages rising still higher, not a reckless oaf who deserved the sack.
Never mind all that. Let it be said loud and clear that Salut! is today full of admiration for the Northern Ireland Chief Justice Sir Brian Kerr. He has just rectified one of the most preposterous judgments I have come across in four decades of attending or taking interest in criminal and civil cases the world over.
Lord Chief Justice Kerr overturned a £25,000 award against a newspaper that published a straightforward example of a restaurant critic doing her job: criticising a restaurant in which she had a meal and dining experience she considered sloppy and unappetising.
Recent Comments