The awards ceremony starts here, after that wholly unrelated picture of the sun setting over the Petra mountains, with the result of the Who Are You? part of the Salut!'s recent competition.
It has been a tough call. The mischief-maker in me wanted to reward Roads of Stone for saying reading Salut! was "a whole lot better than reading the Telegraph".
Vanity would have had me plumping for Jane ("I find your writing amusing, articulate and thought provoking").
A sneaking regard for insolent spirits tempted me to award the prize to Walter Ellis ("Do you ever do any work, Colin? I just wondered") or Marty E for his disdainful take on my attempts to make Salut! viable. Bill, Keith & Co produced their usual entertaining banter. There were words of wit and wisdom from various corners of France and across its border with Switzerland.
In the end, though, I felt the prize - a copy of Résistance: Memoirs of Occupied France, Agnès Humbert's magnificent, if painful, account of imprisonment at the hands of the Nazis - should go to one of the two most intriguing responses.
This one had me wondering what I'd said to put the poor person off:
"Dear Colin; I bookmarked your site when I was considering applying to work for you. It helped me decide against the move.
Yours The Apprentice
PS Blog is v good actually, although would prefer to read more about the everyday life in AD."
But this, from Lynn, gets the prize. I have overlooked the rebellious use of so many of the Americanisms that I ban in my daily work (such as it is, Walter). It wins because it is not really about Salut! at all but identifies a contemporary literary trend in a way that makes me want to explore further:
"I have an apartment in Paris. I administer a Facebook group for folks like me -- English Speakers in France, if you want to look it up. I got well and truly tired of all that sentimental hoo-ha about all those between-the-wars writers who hogged the tables at the cafes. Let's face it, unless they wanted to hit on me, they wouldn't invite me to sit with them, so it's not as if it's a life I could have shared. Recently I have gotten interested in what today's more literary expats are up to. Through the miracle of the Internet, I can now join the table. So, here I am, thank you. It's nice to be invited."
For the second copy of the book, the choice was rather simpler, because fascinating though the replies were, they all came from the same three people.
Bill nearly won the prize for his spectacular but robustly argued misjudgement of Brassed Off. Dumdad also came close with his loyal support of the Salut line (and for his welcome return to blogging after a period of self-imposed silence).
But Keith once again displayed deep knowledge of the period in question and, though I disagree with his analysis, deserves the prize (and will almost certainly find it as gripping as I did).
I loved this riposte to my original challenge to his position:
"Colin, you are right when you say that there would have been acquiescence from the British - but only some. The political scene was very much different and Churchill would have ensured that the truculent British would have fought on, painful though it might have been. Being a natural-born coward, I would have surrendered on the spot to the first passing Bratwurst salesman."
* The winners are asked to supply their postal addresses by contacting me via the e-mail link at the top of this page.
Recent Comments